British Empire Title

The Westcountry Walker: Hiking Through History

From Chudleigh Knighton to Chudleigh: In Search of a Bishop’s Palace


St Paul's Church

Recently we had visited a Bishop’s Palace near Sowton and Clyst St Mary, and just before that we visited the site of another one in Paignton. Clearly the Bishops of Exeter were fond of their palaces, as today we were searching for yet another, this one at Chudleigh. Before searching for this lost palace in Chudleigh, though, we parked in Chudleigh Knighton and began our journey by looking at the beautiful church of St Paul’s.

Sir George Gilbert Scott

St Paul’s is another early Victorian chapel-of-ease dating from the 1840s. One very unusual feature strikes you almost immediately: the church is clad in Haldon flint, said to make it the only flint church in Devon, and finished in Plymouth limestone, probably from the West Hoe quarries that nearly consumed all of Plymouth Hoe before quarrying was curtailed. The church was designed by a young Sir George Gilbert Scott with his partner William Moffatt. Shortly after this commission Scott won the competition to design St Nicholas’s Church in Hamburg, whose spire made it the tallest building in the world when it was finished in 1874. He became one of the leading figures of the Victorian Gothic Revival and worked on many English cathedrals as well as Westminster Abbey, where he was later buried. He was only twenty-nine when he designed this church.

Another notable feature outside the church is the gateway into it, incorporating the names of Chudleigh Knighton’s servicemen who died in the Great War. It was opened in 1922 by Colonel Harold St Maur of Stover House, with 150 ex-servicemen in attendance. It is one of the more unusual First World War memorials, but very effective in that everyone sees it whenever they enter the churchyard and your eyes cannot help but be drawn to the names of the soldiers who lost their lives from this community.

Serendipitously, as we approached the church from the gateway, we could hear organ music from inside. There was no service taking place, but the organist was practising. There is something lovely about hearing a church full of music. The organ is actually upstairs at the back of the church, and would be very visible to anyone in the pews who might turn around to look up there. Usually organists are tucked away coyly in a corner somewhere. The organ sounded in fine fettle too.

The interior is very delicately done with some beautifully understated engraved walls and some interesting stained-glass windows. The east one is a fairly modern one dating from 1961 showing the Trinity but alluding to all sorts of local history and the surrounding community. There really is a lot to see in this one.

St Paul's Church, War Memorial

The church has a beautiful memorial inside the church to its war dead to complement its lovely entranceway. Unlike many memorials it also explains their rank, age, place and year of death, and also the manner of their death, for example, one of them stating that the 19-year-old Alfred Perry of the Devonshire Regiment died a prisoner after the Siege of Kut in Mesopotamia; he died in September 1916 and lies in Baghdad. It never ceases to amaze that such a small community can lose so many of its young to a single war; in this case 18. It is also satisfying to see that someone has gone to a lot of effort to create a book detailing the service of each of these men commemorated. It is always a pleasure to see the stories behind the names on these memorials.

There is a further memorial to William Loyd Milton, a Sergeant in the Devonshires who, it says, after seeing almost the entire war in Gallipoli, Egypt and Palestine, finally fell on 10th September in 1918 just two months before the war ended at the age of 33. Almost certainly the reason for this additional private memorial is that he was the only son of Loyd and Helen Milton who lived at Beal Farm which is literally just over the road from the church. William was with the 16th Devons as they approached the famous Hindenburg Line near Epehy in France. In many ways this was the last line of the German defences and they fought particularly ferociously. The Devons here took so many casualties they were pulled out of the line for a few days to rest and recover. But this wasn’t to last long and soon they were back on the assault. They took 300 casualties in September alone, poor William among them. So near to the end of the war yet so far.

There is a memorial to a soldier who lived out his life and actually became a Colonel in the 13th Lancers of the Indian Army: Michael Edwin Fell (1889 to 1979). He had a fascinating and long life but not without its tragedies. He appears to have joined the Connaught Rangers before the First World War in 1909. During the war he served in Africa, the Western Front and towards the end he seems to have transferred to that new-fangled Tank Corps in 1918. He was to earn the Military Cross for his troubles and later a CBE. After the war he transferred to the Indian Army joining the 13th Lancers who also came under the name of the 13th Duke of Connaught's Own Lancers, continuing his Connaught connections but through the cavalry rather than the infantry. He got married in Calcutta to Margaret Mary King in 1930, who had sadly just lost her father, Commodore Henry Douglas King, the MP for South Paddington, who drowned in August 1930 when his yacht Islander was wrecked in Lantivet Bay near Fowey. He and his wife retired to Devon but sadly this brave warrior was killed prosaically by being hit by a van in Newton Abbot, albeit at the ripe old age of about 90.

There is one memorial that is particularly sad and despite being in Chudleigh Knighton pertains to my neighbourhood in Plymouth. In fact very close to my house indeed. The sad story revolves around three members of the Gibbs family born and brought up in Chudleigh Knighton but all of whom lived in Plymouth during the Blitz. Edward Gibbs, aged 36, was a recently promoted Police Sergeant who lived in Corondale Road, Beacon Park. His brother Sydney, aged 41, lived close by in Merrivale Road and was a Head Air Raid Warden, and Sydney’s 15-year-old son David acted as a messenger boy for the ARP. Tragically all three of them were killed on the same night, 29 April 1941, during the April raids that devastated Plymouth. All three were killed when a bomb landed close to them on the corner of Corondale Road and Beacon Park Road close to both their homes but whilst they were all on duty trying to coordinate rescue attempts. In addition to being remembered in their home village of Chudleigh Knighton they are also remembered on the Plymouth Blitz Memorial in Ford Cemetery. These three men (and the 15-year-old was acting like a man) were as brave as any servicemen who donned a uniform. But what devastation for the rest of the Gibbs family to bear.

General William Templer Hughes

There was one more fascinating memorial in the church from an earlier era. This was of General Sir William Templer Hughes, who was born in 1822 and died in 1897. He joined the Bengal Army in 1842 and was involved in many campaigns, but his memorial points out his service in the important battles of Moodkee (Mudki), Ferozeshah and Sobraon and throughout the Indian Mutiny, during which he commanded the 1st Punjab Cavalry. He also served with one of the most famous units of that campaign, Hodson’s Horse, whose founder William Hodson was killed at Lucknow in March 1858. William Hodson was a larger-than-life character who was one of the most famous actors of the Indian Mutiny. He had personally apprehended the last Mughal Emperor after they recaptured Delhi. Those first three battles were all part of the First Anglo-Sikh War by the East India Company and all three of them were huge and bloody battles. The Sikhs were no primitive army but a well-trained and well-armed and crucially well-motivated army. The resulting battles were bloody but both sides came to respect one another’s performance on the battlefield. Ironically, the Sikhs would soon become some of the most loyal troops to the British in the Indian subcontinent and their intervention in the Indian Mutiny of just a few years later was critical indeed. He had served with the 1st Punjab Cavalry, Hodson’s Horse, the Central India Horse and the Punjab Frontier Force. He retired in 1870. In many ways he was the quintessential Victorian soldier who served overseas his entire professional life. In his case he rose to become a very senior rank indeed.

Bishop’s Palace, Chudleigh

After rummaging around the cemetery we then headed to Chudleigh to search for the Bishop’s Palace. It is marked very prominently on the Ordnance Survey Map but it is located on private land within the grounds of Rock House. We did ask someone if we could take a little peek and we were glad we did so, as we accidentally stumbled not just on the remains of the palace but also some quite impressive hidden gardens, an old quarry rock face and a somewhat intriguing collection of some very, very old-looking junk. It felt as if we had stumbled on a lost world. Appropriately for the quarry the house whose grounds they are located within is called Rock House. Rock House is a Victorian house itself with wonderful views northwards to Dartmoor. No wonder the Bishops wanted a palace on this site. Rock House was used by American soldiers in the Second World War but after the war became a hotel then a market garden and eventually formal gardens open to the public. Sadly this closed to the public in 2016 but you can still see the outline of what must have been quite an idyllic place to visit.

As for the Bishop’s Palace, a Bishop of Exeter chose Chudleigh as the site for one of his rural palaces as early as 1080, very early in the Norman era, and the bishops held on to it for an unusually long time, until 1550, nearly half a millennium later. The ruins you can see today date from the second half of the 13th century. Counter-intuitively, the bishops were at Chudleigh before work had even started on Exeter Cathedral, which wasn’t begun until 1114 and took the best part of three centuries to reach the form we see today. I’ve had builders like that before. The bishop who chose the site was probably Osbern FitzOsbern, a Norman. It had a dual role of being a private residence but could be used for official business. Being on the road from Exeter it would have been relatively easy for the Bishop of Exeter to get to and escape the hubbub of the city for the tranquillity of the Devon countryside. It must have been quite a popular residence for so many Bishops to have used it over the centuries; Bishop Edmund Lacy died here in 1455, which explains the Bishop Lacy name you still see around the town. But, come the Reformation, Bishop John Veysey was forced in 1550, on the order of Edward VI’s government, to give up the manor of Chudleigh, palace and all, and it passed into secular hands. We have come across Edward VI’s reign frequently on our travels, as his uncle and Lord Protector, Edward Seymour, Duke of Somerset, played a major role in provoking the 1549 Prayer Book Rebellion. Somerset was overthrown later that year and was eventually executed on Tower Hill in 1552. The palace though began to fall into serious disrepair not unlike the abbeys and monasteries. Artists started to paint the decaying splendour and over the years nature reclaimed much of it. It is a real shame that these remains are not easily accessible as they were once upon a time a very important part of our landscape and a critical part of our ecclesiastical history. Its fortunes rose and fell with the medieval Catholic Church.

Rupert and I had never been to Chudleigh before and loved seeing all the different styles of house, many revealing the town's relative wealth and importance enhanced by the fact that it lay on a major transportation link between Plymouth and Exeter. With the creation of Plymouth Dock in 1691 and the subsequent rise of the Royal Navy the traffic would increase substantially on this road as Plymouth ballooned in importance in the 18th and early 19th centuries. It is for this reason that as you walk up the Parade and Fore Street many of these buildings would have been inns with lodging or more importantly coaching inns where horses could be changed and long-distance passengers could rest. Chudleigh still has a lot of the old archways signifying where horses and carts could be led around the back to stables, giving the town something of an old-fashioned rural air. The development of the railways in the 19th century saw the death knell for stagecoaches which had always struggled with Devon’s hills and valleys. The main lines from Exeter to Plymouth initially avoided Chudleigh although in 1882 the Teign Valley branch line finally connected Chudleigh to the rail network, at least until passenger trains were withdrawn in 1958. But it was the A38 which finally saw long-distance travel give Chudleigh a wide berth. And the town reverted to its rural beginnings serving the local farming community.

Pynsent's Free School

Just before you get to the imposing St Martin and St Mary Church you catch a glimpse of a plaque on a beautifully old building which, as the plaque explains, used to be Pynsent's Free School. Born in Chudleigh in 1607, John Pynsent trained as a lawyer, married well and became an influential civil servant in the tumultuous years of civil war and its aftermath. Scarred by the divisions of his time in the early years of the Restoration he decided to establish a school in his native Chudleigh to connect education and religion. He created a fund to build a school and to hire “a schoolmaster of good name, manners and teaching and conformable to the Doctrine and Discipline of the Church of England”. Clearly he wanted to help ensure that future generations might not return to the sectarian divisions he had experienced only too well and yet also he was a keen Protestant who wanted the established church to thrive. Its location next to the church is no accident. The school actually functioned until just before the First World War broke out. Sadly John died in August 1668, the year the school was founded, but his will left money to provide free education for the children of the parish as the plaque proudly proclaims: ‘John Pynsent of Lincolnes Inne Esq, boren in this Parish, hath erected this for a Free Schoole & indowed it with Thirtie Poundes per annum for ever. 1668’. The school building could accommodate 20 boys (there was no provision for girls) and lodgings for the schoolmaster. Protestants were particularly keen on promoting education. Most well-to-do families hired governesses and masters to teach their children at home. This is an early example of educational philanthropy expanding educational opportunities to a wider section of society. He himself had come from relatively modest means although his wife was from a significantly richer family and indeed his father-in-law helped purchase the land and property for the endeavour. But still it is a heartening story of someone genuinely trying to give the children of his community better life options.

Now we had intended to look around the church next door, but sadly it was locked. But we would get in touch with the very helpful and responsive vicar who would arrange for it to open for us on our next visit. Which we will share with you shortly: here. But for this adventure we had seen various stages of church influence on our landscape from the Bishops of Exeter wishing to spend time in the serene surroundings of Devon to the philanthropist who wanted education and religion to provide healing in a divided nation and to a unique Victorian church that provided the training and experience for one of the most important Gothic architects of the Victorian era which would see many of our church buildings transformed in their appearance on both the inside and on the outside. Quite a remarkable historical journey spanning nearly a millennium in the short walk from Chudleigh Knighton to Chudleigh itself.

Location of Walk

Click for OS Map of Area

Links

Historic England: Church of St Paul, Chudleigh Knighton (Grade II)
Scott and Moffatt’s flint church of 1841 to 1842

Historic England: War Memorial Gateway, Chudleigh Knighton
Listing entry for the First World War memorial gateway

War Memorials Online: The Gibbs Family Memorial
The plaque to Sydney, David and Edward Gibbs, killed in the Plymouth Blitz

Chudleigh History Group
Local history resources and research for Chudleigh and district

Historic England: Bishop’s Palace, Chudleigh (Scheduled Monument)
Official listing entry for the Bishop’s Palace site

Historic England: The Bishop’s Palace, Chudleigh, an Archaeological Survey
Martin Fletcher’s 1999 survey of the palace remains

Historic England: The Old House (Pynsent’s School)
Listing entry for the former free school of 1668

Devon History Society: Education and Social Change for the Children of Chudleigh
Helen Turnbull’s study of education and philanthropy in Chudleigh

Chudleigh Knighton Phone Box Museum
Local micro-museum housed in the village’s restored phone box

Disused Stations: Chudleigh
Historical overview of Chudleigh’s former railway station

Suggested Reading

The English Church 1066 to 1154
by Barlow, Frank; Longman, 1979

The Buildings of England: Devon
by Cherry, Bridget and Pevsner, Nikolaus; Yale University Press, 2004

The Indian Mutiny: 1857
by David, Saul; Viking, 2002

The Blitz: The British Under Attack
by Gardiner, Juliet; HarperPress, 2010

God’s Architect: Pugin and the Building of Romantic Britain
by Hill, Rosemary; Allen Lane, 2007

A New Survey of England: Devon
by Hoskins, W.G.; Collins, 1954

The First Day on the Somme
by Middlebrook, Martin; Allen Lane, 1971

The Teign Valley Line
by Pomroy, L.W.; Oxford Publishing Co., 1984

The Fall of the Ottomans
by Rogan, Eugene; Allen Lane, 2015

The First Anglo-Sikh War
by Singh, Amarpal; Amberley, 2010

Gothic for the Steam Age: An Illustrated Biography of George Gilbert Scott
by Stamp, Gavin; Aurum Press, 2015

Plymouth: A Shattered City
by Wasley, Gerald; Halsgrove, 2004

More Walks

Walks by the Westcountry Walker

Walks in Cornwall

Walks in Devon

Walks in Somerset

Walks in Hampshire

Walks in Wiltshire

St Paul’s Church, Chudleigh Knighton War memorial archway at the churchyard entrance Interior of St Paul’s Church East stained glass window of St Paul’s
St Paul’s Church, built in 1841 to 1842 by George Gilbert Scott and W. B. Moffatt, showing its flint-clad walls and limestone dressings. The First World War memorial archway forming the entrance to the churchyard, listing the men of Chudleigh Knighton who fell in 1914 to 1918. The simple original interior of St Paul’s, with its lancet windows, timber roof and mid-20th-century fittings. The stepped triple-lancet east window, containing the mid-20th-century stained glass installed in 1961.
Altar of St Paul’s Church Stained glass window on the north wall Organist playing the upstairs organ Rupert standing in the nave looking towards the chancel
The altar of St Paul’s, with its carved stone reredos, crucifix and mid-20th-century stained glass behind it. The stained glass window on the north wall, dedicated to Arthur Christian Baker, set within its carved stone surround. The organist practising at the upstairs organ, showing the pipework and the painted timber roof structure. Rupert standing in the aisle of the nave looking towards the chancel and the east window.
Memorial to Colonel Michael Edwin Fell Memorial to Sergeant William Loyd Milton Memorial to the Gibbs family killed in the Plymouth Blitz Great War memorial plaque listing the fallen of Chudleigh Knighton
Memorial to Colonel Michael Edwin Fell, C.B.E., M.C., of the 13th Lancers, who served in the Connaught Rangers, Tank Corps and Indian Army. The memorial to Sergeant William Loyd Milton, Royal Devon Yeomanry, who served in Gallipoli, Egypt and Palestine before falling in France in 1918. The plaque commemorating Sydney Gibbs, his son David, and Edward Gibbs, all killed during the Plymouth Blitz on 29 April 1941 while on civil defence duty. The Great War memorial plaque listing the men of Chudleigh Knighton who died in the First World War, with details of their service and manner of death.
Memorial to General William Templer Hughes Graveyard outside St Paul’s Church Cat statue on the roof of a village house Entrance to Rock House
The memorial to General William Templer Hughes, K.C.B., recording his service in the Anglo-Sikh Wars and the Indian Mutiny. The graveyard outside St Paul’s Church, with its 19th-century headstones set against the village houses beyond. A cat statue perched on the roof of a village house, a small but distinctive feature of Chudleigh Knighton. The entrance to Rock House, marked by its stone gateposts and the sign identifying the property.
Rock House Remains of the Bishop’s Palace Interior remains of the Bishop’s Palace Collection of old machinery and objects near Rock House
Rock House, the Victorian residence overlooking the site of the Bishop’s Palace, with its curved wings and landscaped frontage. The remains of the Bishop’s Palace, partly hidden within the wooded grounds, showing the surviving stone archway. Interior remains of the Bishop’s Palace, with its thick stone walls, arched openings and later garden additions. A fascinating collection of old machinery, tools and metalwork scattered along the woodland path near Rock House.
Dilapidated horse-drawn carriage in shed Overgrown garden with stonework remains Rock face of the old quarry Quarry face showing old stonecutters’ marks
A dilapidated horse-drawn carriage stored in a shed, with its paintwork, wheels and upholstery showing long-term decay. An overgrown garden area with moss-covered stonework, where the remains of an old structure are gradually being reclaimed by vegetation. The rock face of the old quarry, showing the exposed stratified stone and the natural regrowth around its base. The quarry face where the old quarryworkers’ marks can still be seen, showing where stone was cut away by hand.
Pynsent’s Free School beside St Martin and St Mary Church Plaque commemorating John Pynsent’s Free School, 1668 St Martin and St Mary Church, Chudleigh Bishop Lacy Takeaway in Chudleigh
Pynsent’s Free School of 1668 beside St Martin and St Mary Church, founded and endowed by John Pynsent for the education of local children. The 1668 plaque recording John Pynsent’s foundation of a free school, set into the wall outside the church. St Martin and St Mary Church, with its battlemented tower and surrounding churchyard. The Bishop Lacy takeaway, named after Bishop Edmund Lacy, who died at the Bishop’s Palace in Chudleigh in 1455.
Whitsley House beside St Martin and St Mary Church Georgian townhouse in Chudleigh Another Georgian townhouse in Chudleigh Street scene of Fore Street, Chudleigh
Whitsley House beside St Martin and St Mary Church, forming part of the historic group around the churchyard. One of Chudleigh’s Georgian townhouses, with its symmetrical façade and classical detailing. A second Georgian townhouse in the town centre, showing the characteristic sash windows and balanced proportions. A view along Fore Street, with its traditional shopfronts, the Post Office and the Red Lion sign further up the hill.

Walks by the Westcountry Walker
Armed Forces | Art and Culture | Articles | Biographies | Colonies | Discussion | Glossary | Hiking | Home | Library | Links | Map Room | Sources and Media | Science and Technology | Search | Student Zone | Timelines | TV and Film | Wargames
Donate by Stephen Luscombe