British Empire Title

The Westcountry Walker: Hiking Through History

Chilthorne Domer: The Pinwill Sisters’ First Commission


St Mary's Church in Chilthorne Domer

On Friday Rupert and I were roaming wide and stopped off in the delightful village of Chilthorne Domer in Somerset to break up a return journey from Bristol. In particular we wanted to see St Mary's church which has a fascinating connection to Devon's ecclesiastical history. The unusual name is another one of those hybrid names; in this case it combines an old British hill name (Cilterne in the Domesday Book, from a Celtic word meaning high) with the name of the Domer family, the medieval knights who held the manor. These dual names allowed the existing population to continue to use their old place names, but the added family name also assigned ownership and reinforced the idea that there were new lords and rulers in the area. Interestingly in the case of Chilthorne Manor, one of the Domer family lies in effigy in the church itself next to the altar in the chancel reminding the local population who their betters were long after he had died. Now, though, these recumbent figures remind us of a turbulent past that has long since passed; they have become part of the decoration of our churches, and we look on these armoured knights in their full battle regalia with more awe than fear.

Pinwill Sisters

The other reason we stopped off at this beautiful church was to see the very first commission of the famous Pinwill Sisters from Ermington in Devon, where their father was the rector. These are the same Pinwills who carved the magnificent rood screen in Lewtrenchard that we mentioned last week. These sisters really challenge our preconceptions of what Victorian women could achieve and from such a young age too. Reverend Edmund Pinwill had seven daughters but no sons. In the 1880s their church in Ermington was being restored under the architect Edmund Sedding, and three of the daughters, Mary, Ethel and Violet, were captivated by the process and begged their parents to let them learn the skills from the artisans and architects working in their father’s church. To say they were fast learners is something of an understatement. This Chilthorne Domer reredos is phenomenal in quality and especially so when you consider that Mary was only 18, Ethel 17 and Violet (who would go on to be the most famous of them all) was only 15. The photograph of them demonstrating their work in Plymouth before the panels were taken to this church in Somerset reveals their youth all too clearly. It should be said that they were still receiving training and guidance, but even so, the quality and intricacy for teenage girls is phenomenal. The Pinwills would soon join the pantheon of great ecclesiastical craftsmen, especially those specialising in the more ornate Anglo-Catholic style, and Violet carried on working until shortly before her death in 1957. Their work can be seen in over 180 churches across the Westcountry and beyond, but the very first one was here in Chilthorne Domer!

The church is constructed out of the local Hamstone which looks so vibrant in the sun. It does tend to weather a little faster than other building materials so our Domer knight looks far older than many contemporary knights carved out of more durable materials, but it has an elegance all of its own and was probably much easier for the stonemasons to work with.

The Domer effigy shows a knight in full chain mail with gauntlets and a flowing surcoat. A helmet provides his pillow whilst his right hand grasps his sword handle. For a long time it was assumed that the effigy was a 14th Century effigy of Sir William Domer but now the consensus is that it is probably older than that, dating from around 1275, and so potentially a 13th-century ancestor of his. The decaying Hamstone has not helped the dating process.

Frank Holsgrove

As always there are some remarkable memorials in the church. One is to Frank Holsgrove who, it explains, was one of the officers of HMS Serpent, which was wrecked off the northwest coast of Spain in 1890. She was effectively a brand new ship, having been completed at Devonport Dockyard in 1888. She was en route to the West Africa Station when she was caught in an enormous storm in the Bay of Biscay and ran aground near Camariñas on the Galician coast, a loss that the court martial put down to navigational error in the diabolical conditions. Only 3 of the 176 crew survived the ordeal. Sadly Frank Holsgrove was not one of those three.

Another memorial remembers the Reverend Robert Palmer, who not only had been rector of Chilthorne Domer for 24 years but had previously been a missionary in China in the 1870s for the Church Missionary Society in Ningpo and Shaoxing in northern Zhejiang province. Ningpo had been one of the Treaty Ports opened to British trade after the First Opium War, and it was caught up in the Taiping Rebellion of the 1850s and 1860s, often described as the bloodiest civil war in history. The Taiping rebels occupied Ningpo itself for five months in 1861 and 1862 before British and French warships helped drive them out, and much of the surrounding province was devastated by the fighting. Going to Zhejiang in the aftermath of this brutal war would have been an extremely brave endeavour indeed. There is also a beautiful stained glass window dedicated to him.

We also can see the memorial to the Reverend William Taylor Dixon and his wife Jane who both died within weeks of each other in 1884. It was their deaths that prompted their children to renovate the church and commission the Pinwill sisters in their parents’ honour. There is also a beautiful stained glass window dedicated to them.

Then there is the sad First World War memorial to Theodore Stewart Wolton Warren, 2nd Lieutenant of the 17th Durham Light Infantry and the son of the Reverend Charles Theodore Warren, rector of the church at the time. Lieutenant Warren was killed on the Somme near Pozières on 17 July 1916, aged 20, and is also named on the Thiepval Memorial. Fascinatingly, he is also commemorated on a war memorial in Japan, in the Foreign General Cemetery at Motomachi in Yokohama. The explanation is that he was born in Japan: his father had been a Church Missionary Society missionary in Osaka from 1890 to 1910, following in the footsteps of his own father, a pioneer missionary there. It is a reminder too that, although we often think of British and Japanese soldiers fighting against one another in the Second World War, they were firm allies in the First World War, when British troops fought alongside the Japanese army to evict the Germans from their Treaty Port at Tsingtao in China in 1914.

Piers Thomas Simon

There are two interesting graves outside which again have international connotations. The first is actually a recent one from Boxing Day 2004. You might remember that date as the day when the Indian Ocean tsunami killed more than 200,000 people in countries all around its shores. One of those was Piers Thomas Simon, who was killed whilst on holiday at Koh Phi Phi in Thailand, aged 33. He was celebrating Christmas with his brother and a girlfriend, waiting for a boat on the beach, when the tsunami came smashing in. In the chaos and debris Piers saved the girlfriend’s life by freeing her from where she was pinned by rubble, but did so at the cost of his own life. Out of this tragedy his younger brother and his parents set up the Piers Simon Appeal, initially to help those affected by the disaster. Since 2009 its School in a Bag initiative has provided everything that a child might need to restart their education. The charity, still based here in Chilthorne Domer, has distributed around 150,000 bags of school supplies in more than 50 countries, all in characteristic red rucksacks in remembrance of the red t-shirt Piers was wearing when he was washed away.

Richard Wyndham Madden

The other grave is also surprisingly contemporary. It is that of Richard Wyndham Madden of the Light Dragoons. The grave looks like a Commonwealth War Graves Commission grave but is subtly different. This is an MOD grave for a Light Dragoons lieutenant who was killed in Bosnia on 28 January 1996, aged 25. He had only been with the peacekeeping force for a matter of weeks when his Spartan armoured vehicle ran over a landmine near Titov Drvar, killing him and two others. The fact that the Madden family have sacrificed so much for this country is also revealed in the lychgate, where his name joins two brothers from an earlier generation. Lieutenant Keith Madden, who had been awarded the Military Cross, was killed in Tunisia on 3 March 1943 with the Royal Artillery, aged just 20; he has no known grave and is named on the Medjez-el-Bab Memorial. His elder brother Major David Madden, also of the Royal Artillery, was killed at Arnhem on 21 September 1944, aged 25, while serving on the headquarters staff of the 1st Airborne Division. He had been injured in a car accident only two days before the landings but went to Arnhem regardless. He is buried at Oosterbeek, and his headstone remembers his brother Keith too.

We did explore the village of Chilthorne Domer afterwards, but we had spent far too long in the church to do it justice. But I love the fact that you can find so many interesting stories in pretty much every church in the land, although always with an incredible diversity of fascinating backstories and connections. The real reason was to see the Pinwills’ first commission, and when you realise their youth and inexperience you are in awe at what they were capable of producing. But once you are inside these time capsules of our history there is so much more to see too.

Location of Walk

Click for OS Map of Area

Links

Wikipedia: Chilthorne Domer
The village, its Domesday name and the Domer family

Historic England: St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer
Grade II* listing entry, including the effigy of about 1275

Historic England: Chilthorne Domer War Memorial
Listing entry for the village war memorial

Wikipedia: The Pinwill Sisters
Mary, Ethel and Violet Pinwill, the woodcarvers of Ermington and Plymouth

Pinwill Sisters: Chilthorne Domer Reredos
Catalogue entry for the sisters’ first ecclesiastical commission

Wikipedia: HMS Serpent (1887)
The torpedo cruiser wrecked off Galicia in November 1890

Wikipedia: Occupation of Ningbo
The Taiping occupation of the treaty port in 1861 and 1862

National Army Museum: Siege of Tsingtao
British and Japanese troops fighting side by side in China in 1914

Light Dragoons: Lieutenant Richard Madden
Killed by a mine in Bosnia on 28 January 1996

ParaData: Major David Madden
Account of Major Madden, killed at Arnhem in 1944

School in a Bag
The charity founded in memory of Piers Simon

Five Crosses Benefice: Our Churches
Parish information for Chilthorne Domer and neighbouring churches

Suggested Reading

Somerset: The Complete Guide
by Bush, Robin; Dovecote Press, 1994

Somerset Churches and Chapels: Building, Repair and Restoration
by Dunning, Robert; Somerset Books, 2007

The Siege of Tsingtao
by Fenby, Jonathan; Penguin, 2014

England’s Thousand Best Churches
by Jenkins, Simon; Allen Lane, 1999

Arnhem 1944: The Airborne Battle
by Middlebrook, Martin; Viking, 1994

The Buildings of England: Somerset: South and West
by Orbach, Julian and Pevsner, Nikolaus; Yale University Press, 2014

Autumn in the Heavenly Kingdom: China, the West and the Epic Story of the Taiping Civil War
by Platt, Stephen R.; Atlantic Books, 2012

English Church Monuments in the Middle Ages
by Saul, Nigel; Oxford University Press, 2009

The Remarkable Pinwill Sisters: From ‘Lady Woodcarvers’ to Professionals
by Wilson, Helen; Willow Productions, 2021

More Walks

Walks by the Westcountry Walker

Walks in Cornwall

Walks in Devon

Walks in Somerset

Walks in Hampshire

Walks in Wiltshire

St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer, south elevation with bell turret Hamstone cross on the porch gable at Chilthorne Domer Chancel gable cross at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Medieval south porch door with ironwork and sanctuary ring
St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer, showing the Hamstone walls and bell turret. The Hamstone cross on the south porch gable. The chancel gable cross above the east end of the church. The medieval south porch door with early iron strap hinges.
Brass memorial to 2nd Lieutenant Theodore Stewart Wolton Warren Memorial tablets to Frank Holsgrove and Sarah Little Holsgrove Rectors’ board listing incumbents from 1207 to 2011 Interior view showing font and wall monument
Brass memorial to 2nd Lieutenant Theodore Warren, killed on the Somme in 1916 aged twenty. Memorial tablets to Frank Holsgrove, lost in the wreck of H.M.S. Serpent in 1890, and to Sarah Little Holsgrove, who died in 1917. The rectors’ board listing the incumbents of Chilthorne Domer from 1207 to 2011 including the ministry of the Reverend Charles Theodore Warren. Interior view showing the fifteenth-century font and the wall monument beneath the painted arch text.
Carved Hamstone head corbel at Chilthorne Domer Marble tablet to John Bayly and his wives Lucy and Mary Memorial tablet to the Reverend Robert Palmer Marble memorial to the Reverend William Taylor Dixon and Jane Isabella Dixon
Carved Hamstone head corbel from the chancel arch. Marble tablet to John Bayly, vicar for forty-three years, and to his wives Lucy and Mary. Memorial tablet to the Reverend Robert Palmer, missionary in China and rector for twenty-four years. Marble memorial to the Reverend William Dixon and Jane Isabella Dixon erected by parishioners in 1887.
Stained glass window showing the Adoration of the Magi dedicated to Robert Palmer and his wife Jessie View along the nave of St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer, towards the font and chancel arch Stained glass window depicting two saints with children, illuminated by sunlight Elaborately carved wooden reredos with Gothic tracery and vine motifs at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer
Stained glass window showing the Adoration of the Magi, dedicated in 1934 to the Reverend Robert Palmer and his wife Jessie. View along the nave towards the fifteenth-century font and chancel arch with the inscription “In All Thy Ways Acknowledge Him”. Stained glass window depicting saints with children, the light casting coloured reflections across the stone sill. Elaborately carved wooden reredos with Gothic tracery and vine motifs, part of the Pinwill Sisters’ early work at Chilthorne Domer.
Recumbent effigy of a medieval knight in the north wall recess at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Seventeenth-century oak pulpit with carved panels and tester canopy at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Carved Hamstone corbel head on the chancel arch at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Stained glass window depicting Christ the Good Shepherd in memory of Maud Elizabeth Palmer, 1896
Recumbent effigy of a knight in chain mail, c.1275, set in a segmental arched recess in the north wall of the sanctuary. Seventeenth-century oak pulpit with carved panels and tester canopy, retaining its original moulded detail and linenfold patterning. Carved Hamstone corbel head on the chancel arch, one of several medieval figures supporting the roof timbers. Stained glass window depicting Christ the Good Shepherd, in memory of Maud Elizabeth Palmer, who died at Chilthorne Rectory on 12 July 1896 aged 18.
Three-panel carved oak reredos by the Pinwill Sisters, showing the Nativity, Ascension and Last Supper at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Chancel of St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer, showing the Pinwill reredos and stained glass east window Marble memorial to Elizabeth Browne, wife of Wadham Lyte Browne, dated 1794 Stained glass window depicting an angel with palm branch and ornate robes at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer
Three-panel carved oak reredos by the Pinwill Sisters, their first commission, showing the Nativity, Ascension and Last Supper. The chancel with the Pinwill reredos and stained glass east window, forming the focal point of the restored interior. Marble memorial to Elizabeth Browne, wife of Wadham Lyte Browne, who died in 1794 aged 61, commemorated for her charitable works. Stained glass window depicting an angel with palm branch, part of the late-Victorian glazing scheme in the chancel.
Carved pew end with peacock motif and floral pattern at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Bell turret with stone cross and arched openings at St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer Exterior view of St Mary’s Church, Chilthorne Domer, showing crenellated parapet and bell turret Grave of Piers Thomas Simon, died 2004, marked by a circular stone memorial in the churchyard at Chilthorne Domer
Carved pew end with peacock motif and floral pattern, part of the Pinwill Sisters’ early woodwork at Chilthorne Domer. Bell turret with stone cross and arched openings, built in Hamstone and typical of Somerset church design. Exterior view of St Mary’s Church showing the crenellated parapet, bell turret and south porch in golden Hamstone. Grave of Piers Thomas Simon, died 2004 on Koh Phi Phi, Thailand, aged 33, marked by a circular stone memorial in the churchyard.
Commemorative lamp erected by parishioners of Chilthorne Domer to mark the coronation of King George VI in 1937 War memorial cross at Chilthorne Domer listing local men who died in the First World War and later conflicts Lychgate memorial plaque honouring Lieutenant Keith Madden, Major David Madden and Lieutenant Richard Madden School in a Bag sign for the Piers Simon Appeal, mounted on a wooden building near Chilthorne Domer
Commemorative lamp erected by parishioners of Chilthorne Domer to celebrate the coronation of King George VI on 12 May 1937. War memorial cross listing local men who died in the First World War and later conflicts, including Lieutenant Richard Madden killed in Bosnia in 1996. Lychgate memorial plaque honouring Lieutenant Keith Madden, Major David Madden and Lieutenant Richard Madden, who fell in Tunisia, at Arnhem and in Bosnia. School in a Bag location for the Piers Simon Appeal, a local charity founded in memory of Piers Simon to support children’s education worldwide.

Walks by the Westcountry Walker
Armed Forces | Art and Culture | Articles | Biographies | Colonies | Discussion | Glossary | Hiking | Home | Library | Links | Map Room | Sources and Media | Science and Technology | Search | Student Zone | Timelines | TV and Film | Wargames
Donate by Stephen Luscombe