Our route eventually brought us back towards Poundsgate, where we had hoped to finish the day with a drink at the Tavistock Inn. Whether it is open seems to depend on a mixture of luck, timing and perhaps the mood of the moor itself, but even shuttered it remains one of Dartmoor’s most atmospheric old hostelries. There has been an inn here since at least the fifteenth century, serving travellers on the lonely routes between Ashburton, Tavistock and the scattered farms of the high ground. Its position at a crossroads, with little else around it, tells you everything about the sort of place it once was: a welcome fire, a tankard of cider, and a roof over your head before the weather closed in.
The Tavistock Inn has accumulated stories in the way that only Dartmoor buildings seem able to do, and none is more famous than the tale of the Evil Rider. The legend is tied to the great storm of 1638, when Widecombe Church — the so‑called Cathedral of the Moor — was struck by a violent thunderclap during a Sunday service. The congregation had crowded inside seeking shelter as the weather worsened, only for the pinnacle of the tower to come crashing through the roof in a shower of stone and lightning. Many were injured, though remarkably none were killed. The people of the moor have never doubted the cause: they say the Devil himself was abroad that afternoon.
According to the story, the trouble began not in Widecombe but here at Poundsgate. The usual Sunday company had gathered in the inn, exchanging gossip and working through the local cider, when the sound of approaching hooves broke the quiet. Something about the rhythm unsettled them. It was not a horse they recognised, and the countryside outside had fallen strangely still. Curiosity eventually pushed one of the drinkers to the window, where he saw a tall, dark figure on a coal‑black horse, the animal stamping and snorting so fiercely that sparks flew from the stones. The rider demanded a flagon of cider in a voice that seemed to shake the doorframe. The landlady, trembling, took it out to him. He drained it in one swallow, tossed her two coins, and rode off towards Widecombe at a speed no ordinary horse could manage.
What happened next is the part everyone knows. The rider tethered his horse to the church tower, peered inside, and spotted a boy who had nodded off during the sermon. That, the story says, was all the invitation he needed. He swept down through the roof, seized the child, and burst back upwards with such force that the pinnacle of the tower snapped away and crashed into the nave below. The thunderclap that followed was said to be the sound of the Devil’s horse launching itself skyward with its captive across the saddle. The boy was never seen again.
Back at Poundsgate, the drinkers heard the hooves returning — a furious gallop from the direction of Widecombe, rising to a crescendo and then fading into the distance. No one dared look out this time. Only when the noise had gone did someone suggest checking the coins the landlady had been given. The money had vanished, replaced by two withered leaves. She declared she had known all along that nothing good would come of it, but one of the older men in the bar offered a different explanation: the pixies, he said, had swapped the coins to protect her from evil. Better a handful of leaves than the Devil’s own payment.
Whether any of this happened is beside the point. The story has clung to the Tavistock Inn for nearly four centuries, helped by its lonely setting and the moor’s long memory for such things. More reliable history tells us that Roundhead gunners were billeted here during the Civil War, and that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle is said to have stayed while researching The Hound of the Baskervilles. But it is the tale of the Evil Rider that gives the place its particular atmosphere. Even on a quiet afternoon, with the shutters drawn and no sign of life inside, you can almost imagine the sound of hooves on the road and a dark figure pausing for a drink before riding on into the storm.